Do Your Male Friends Impact Your Dating Life?

(This is cross-posted at BlogHer.)

I have a number of really good friends who are males. I’ve known some of them for years (even if I don’t see them very often in person anymore), I met a few of them over the internet (I’ve seen them in person once or twice, but most of our contact is via blogs and email), and there are several guys that I hang out with on a regular basis. I don’t want to date any of these men; I place a huge value on their friendship and my life is better because they’re a part of it.

In fact, sometimes I disclose things to my male friends that I don’t talk about with my girlfriends. It’s not because I think the women wouldn’t want to hear it; I just like going to the guys for advice because I enjoy getting a male perspective on things. And you know what? A vast majority of the time, I receive terrific advice. I can think of one example in particular where I asked a male friend how I should handle a situation with another guy — but I didn’t follow the advice he gave me, and I regretted it afterwards. (Arrgghhh…hindsight.)

(I also wrote about a situation recently where two of my guy friends rescued me from boredom on a Saturday night. It really made me realize how lucky I am to know people who will go out of their way like that.)

I have another example that came up not long ago. I had dated a guy for a few weeks back in November, but we’d stopped seeing each other before Thanksgiving. Several weeks passed and I was thinking about emailing him — you know, just to say hi and ask how he was doing — but before I did, I decided to consult a few of my guy friends and ask what they thought.

Both of them said the same thing: since we hadn’t split on bad terms, it wouldn’t hurt to send this guy an email. But, they said…he knows how to reach you. If he really wants to talk to you, he’ll make the effort to do so. One of my friends wrote this line, and it’s stuck with me ever since: “On the whole, I know this — you’re too good for people who can’t be bothered to call you back.”

Isn’t that fantastic? It was written by an internet-friend who’s married and has a family. We never hang out in person. But I count him as a friend, and I love that I can email him when I have a problem (or when I don’t have a problem, of course) and he’s always there with a response.

I started thinking about my guy friends after I read the post Liz wrote on BlogHer: I Don’t Get Girls’ Night. As much as she enjoys her regular monthly get-togethers with her female friends, Liz said she would prefer if males were included as well. Unsurprisingly, I’m in complete agreement. There are definitely situations where I hang out with my girlfriends without a male around, but in my mind there’s no reason to specifically shut them out.

One of the things Liz touched on was that some of the husbands/boyfriends of the ladies in her group might not feel comfortable if the group was mixed-sex, which is one of the reasons they keep it women-only. While it could be easy to say, “These people are just friends! It’s dumb for their partners to get jealous!” I understand that it’s a very real issue.

I’ve dated guys who knew I have male friends that I hang out with, and while they haven’t specifically said they don’t like it, I’ve gotten some questions. One of the most popular questions (after I assure them I’m not physically attracted to my guy friends and we don’t enjoy “benefits”) is, “But they think you’re hot, right?”

What does that mean? Like, even though I’ve said that I don’t think of them that way, if my guy friends think I’m hot there’s always the possibility I’ll act on it? I’m sure that’s what they’re trying to infer, but…no. There have been plenty of situations where I’ve gotten intoxicated with a guy friend, and there’s never been one single instance where I’ve felt the need to rip their clothes off (or even, to a lesser extent, make out with them).

My response to that question is, “Maybe they do [think I'm hot]. But if so, it’s never a big deal because we don’t go around talking about it and they never try to act on it.” (Actually, one of my guy friends will sometimes make appreciative remarks about certain features of my anatomy, and a guy I work with always points out when I’m dressed especially nice, but it’s all in good fun — I probably wouldn’t mention that to someone I’m dating, though.)

In the past, I did find myself hanging out with my guy friends less when I dated someone who felt threatened by it. But that was when I wasn’t holding my head up with confidence the way I should have. And you know what? When I stopped dating that person, who were the ones that immediately stepped back into my life? Yep, you got it.

That’s when I told myself that I’m not giving up my guy friends for anyone. We have fun together. They support me. They’re important to me. They don’t deserve to be ditched just because someone doesn’t trust me. I’m a loyal and trustworthy person, and that extends 100% to my dating life. My friends are my friends, and my guy is my guy. If he doesn’t realize that, he doesn’t know me.

Do your male friends impact your dating life at all?

Related Reading:

While it’s good to have male friends while you’re in a relationship, there are certain factors you have to keep in mind. Mrs. Dub does a good job of answering the question, “Is it kosher to have good friends of the opposite sex after you’re married?”

[W]hat does a friendship entail? The occasional email or phone call? Meeting up for lunch along with your spouse or the guy’s spouse? Because all of that is kosher in my opinion. The more alone time and more secrecy involved, the more likely you are putting your friendship and marriage in jeopardy, or at least ticking off someone’s spouse.

Amelia at The Frisky says, Let’s Hear It For The Boys!

[W]hen word started to get around that my relationship was stalled or over…so many of my friends offered their support. I expected as much from my female friends — you can always count on the ladies to help you numb the pain of a breakup with wine and a little smacktalk — but I didn’t expect my guy friends to be equally as empathetic.

As a lesbian, Zoe thought it was strange when a heterosexual friend mentioned that she thought her husband needed to have more “guy friends.” (Zoe said, “The funny thing is, he seems to not really care, or find it as important as she does, for him to have ‘guy friends’ to do stuff with.”) She wonders if gay couples look at friendships and relationships differently than straight couples do.

Melissa writes about the types of Guy Friends Every Girl Needs.

The Bachelor Guy talks about why it’s good for guys to have female friends.

8 Comments



  1. My male friends have a pretty big impact. If they don’t like the guy I’m dating, they’ll tell me, and then I’m likely to take a second look and see if their reasoning is justified.

    The majority of my friends are male, so I make a point of letting that be known upfront when I start dating a guy. I wouldn’t want him to give up his female friends, either, just because we started dating!

    Posted December 23, 2008 at 10:52 am #
  2. well, i can’t really answer the main question. but guys do often have really useful things to say. even the most knuckle-dragging ones of us do *some* thinking at least sometimes. so i’m glad you’re finding that in balance.

    Posted December 23, 2008 at 12:12 pm #
  3. I think a good girls’ night is in order MAYBE once a month. Any more than that, and the estrogen overload starts to make me crazy…

    Posted December 23, 2008 at 2:01 pm #
  4. Turning it around to apply to me: I have a lot of female (non-romantic/sexual) friends — in many ways I relate better to women than to men — and it’s mostly not been a problem. But there are two parallel issues:

    1. When I’m in a relationship, does my partner have a problem with my other friendships? I’ve had two relationships that I can think of, over the years, that didn’t take off because of this. In both cases, it wasn’t anything specific to me, but a general thing that the woman in question couldn’t accept her mate having lots of female friends. There was a lot I liked about both women, but in the end I think it was best: we couldn’t really have lasted with that sort of unfounded jealousy.

    2. When I’m not in a relationship, does the presence of my female friends deter women who might be interested in me (or I in them)? That’s definitely more of an issue. I’ve often found that women stay clear, assuming that the woman I’m hanging out with is my girlfriend. And it’s sometimes hard to dissuade them from that belief even if I approach them directly. On the other hand, I’m not going to stop going out with my women friends for that reason.

    I figure that the best I can do is to make it clear to potential romantic partners that my friends are my friends, and that’s all. And there will always be those who think that men and women can’t be “just friends” together. ‘s not true.

    Posted December 23, 2008 at 2:20 pm #
  5. ““But they think you’re hot, right?”

    What does that mean? Like, even though I’ve said that I don’t think of them that way, if my guy friends think I’m hot there’s always the possibility I’ll act on it?”"

    No, it means that he thinks that your guy friends would jump in the sack with you if it appeared to be possible. He is probably of the opinion that they aren’t interested if you aren’t offering.

    “My response to that question is, “Maybe they do [think I’m hot]. But if so, it’s never a big deal because we don’t go around talking about it and they never try to act on it.””

    At least a few of them never got the sack to ask you out/make a move. It’s just the law of averages.

    Boomhauer
    Posted December 23, 2008 at 8:40 pm #
  6. wanted to pop in and wish you a happy holiday and thank you again for linking the donation give.

    Im totaling and posting today!

    Posted December 24, 2008 at 6:58 am #
  7. i have male friends and it doesn’t impact my dating life (when i had one) or my relationships. i wouldn’t be in a relationship with a guy who was insecure about me having male friends.

    i do like hanging out just with my female friends though, and it’s because i feel like we (really them more than me imo) act differently when guys are around. they are less likely to be goofy and talk about private or girly things. but it’s rare that men are forbidden from joining us. just this week, i got my girlfriends together for dinner and to go to rock n shop. i didn’t invite any guys, but when one of the women wanted to bring her boyfriend, i wasn’t like “no, he can’t come because he has a penis.” but it did change the vibe of the evening.

    classic jen
    Posted December 24, 2008 at 10:35 pm #
  8. Some of my best female friends are girls I’ve dated. I think they’re invaluable as friends and give me insight into things my guy friends can’t.

    Posted December 26, 2008 at 11:14 am #

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*